The Primary Care Companion
For CNS Disorders

CME Institute

Home | About Us | Mission Statement | All CME Activities | MyCME | CME Facebook | CME Twitter

JCP

Home | About JCP | Subscribe | Archive | Information for Authors | Information for Reviewers | Information for Advertisers | Customer Service | JCP Facebook | JCP Twitter

PCC

Home | About PCC | Register | Archive | Information for Authors | Information for Reviewers | PCC Facebook | PCC Twitter

Help

FAQ | About Psychiatrist.com | Terms of use | Privacy policy

magnifying glass for search

  • magnifying glass for search
  • Advanced Search

Login

Login  
Login | Login Help | Register | Subscribe
Register | Elerts

Quick Links

Font: A | A | A

Top

Purchase PDF

Printer-Friendly Copy

Vol 18, No 5
Table of Contents

Facebook ShareShare

twitter shareTweet This

envelope iconEmail a link

Related ►

Related Articles

[X]

<p class="frontmatter-fieldnotes disclaimernew" style="margin-bottom:15px;">This work may not be copied, distributed, displayed, published, reproduced, transmitted, modified, posted, sold, licensed, or used for commercial purposes. By downloading this file, you are agreeing to the publisher’s <a href="/pages/termsofuse.aspx" target="_blank">Terms & Conditions</a>.</p> <div id="_idContainer000">
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-title"><span class="bold"><a id="_idTextAnchor000"></a>Assisted Decision Making Using Direct Counseling in a Pregnant Woman With Major Depressive Disorder</span></p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text"><span class="semibold">To the Editor:</span> Major depression that occurs during pregnancy affects a woman’s judgment in making decisions related to the pregnancy and the fetus, including the decision about whether to continue a pregnancy. The psychiatrist should balance respect for the autonomy of the depressed woman with beneficence-based obligations to the pregnant woman and also to the fetus, when the fetus is viable.<span class="htm-cite"><a href="#ref1">1</a></span> Coverdale et al<span class="htm-cite"><a href="#ref2">2</a></span> have discussed the clinical implications of respect for autonomy in the psychiatric treatment of pregnant patients with depression and have recommended strategies for assessing decision-making abilities and for enhancing their autonomy. They suggest that nondirective counseling be used when the fetus is pre-viable and that directive counseling is ethically justifiable when the fetus is viable. Nondirective counseling means discussing various alternatives for the outcome of the pregnancy but not recommending any of them in particular. In contrast, directive counseling recommends management based on either maternal or fetal indications. Here, I present the use of directive counseling to assist decision making in a pregnant woman with major depression.</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text">&nbsp;</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text"><span class="semibold-ital">Case report.</span><span class="italic"> </span>Ms A, a 27-year-old woman, was orphaned as an infant. She was admitted to a general hospital in Taiwan because of recurrent suicidal attempts by jumping from height and hanging. The Beck Suicidal Intent Scale<span class="htm-cite"><a href="#ref3">3</a></span> revealed “high intent” in assessing the severity of her suicide attempt. Diagnostic interview revealed a major depressive disorder, recurrent episode (<span class="italic">DSM-IV-TR</span>). Little was known about her day-to-day life. She was unable to work and received disability benefits. Further examination revealed that she was pregnant at 26 weeks. Ms A had variable autonomy to deliver the fetus because the pregnancy was a result of sexual assault and concern about her ability to parent. When asked who helps her make tough decisions, she replied “no one.” Since artificial abortion was forbidden after 24 weeks’ gestational age (GA) in Taiwan, the psychiatrist asked the Medical Ethics Committee (MEC) for advice. </p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text">The MEC called a meeting with the departments of psychiatry, pediatrics, obstetrics, and social work to help devise a strategy to respect both the patient’s reproductive freedom and the life of the fetus. It was decided that Ms A should be given an antidepressant to help improve her autonomy. After reviewing the antidepressants used in her previous major depressive episodes, duloxetine was found to have been well-tolerated and shown better response than other antidepressants. It also had minimal abnormal outcomes on the fetus.<span class="htm-cite"><a href="#ref4">4</a></span> Duloxetine was then chosen to treat this major depressive episode. The MEC met with Ms A 3 weeks later and provided directive counseling for her. The MEC invited her to consider her previous and current values regarding the pregnancy and motherhood. She was then assisted in making a decision, based on her values, that she continue the pregnancy to term and place the baby into the adoption process. After a 6-week hospital admission, Ms A gave premature birth to a healthy baby that was 38.5 cm (15.2 in) long and weighed 1,740 g (3.8 lb; G1P1, GA 32 weeks). While recovering from depression, Ms A’s free-will decision was confirmed by two psychiatrists, and a public notary from the District Court began the adoption process.</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text">&nbsp;</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text">The treatment of depression during pregnancy poses serious ethical challenges to the clinician. Health care providers have to be sensitive to the issues of autonomy, the levels of which may vary.<span class="htm-cite"><a href="#ref1">1</a></span> In this case, Ms A was recommended a trial with an antidepressant, which may have helped improve her autonomy within a time frame that would allow her to attend to, absorb, retain, and recall relevant information provided by the MEC. In this case, the fetus, because it was viable, was considered a patient independent of Ms A’s autonomy.<span class="htm-cite"><a href="#ref2">2</a></span> When the fetus is a patient, both Ms A and the MEC have beneficence-based obligations to the fetus. The baby was 2 months premature and was placed for adoption smoothly.</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text">In pregnancy, the possible risks of medication to mother and fetus, including toxic effects, should be cautiously balanced with the likely benefits.<span class="htm-cite"><a href="#ref1">1</a>,<a href="#ref2">2</a></span> There was an analysis<span class="htm-cite"><a href="#ref5">5</a></span> of pregnancy outcome data regarding duloxetine captured in the Lilly Safety System and the US Food and Drug Administration’s Adverse Events Reporting System database. Of the 233 prospectively reported cases, pregnancy outcomes were normal in 143 cases and abnormal in 90 cases. Abnormal pregnancy outcomes were mainly spontaneous abortions, postnatal or perinatal conditions, or premature births. In this case, the baby was 2 months premature, which might be related to duloxetine exposure during pregnancy.</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text">The clinician faces an ethical dilemma when it comes to respecting the autonomy of a depressed pregnant patient whose decision-making capacity may be impaired.<span class="htm-cite"><a href="#ref1">1</a></span> The clinician also needs to protect the rights of the viable fetus.<span class="htm-cite"><a href="#ref2">2</a></span> In this situation, directive counseling integrated by a team such as the MEC could assist decision making for the patient and secure the proper rights for the baby, as in the presented case.</p>
  <p class="references_references-heading"><span class="smallcaps">References</span></p>
  <p class="references-references-text-1-9"><a name="ref1"></a><span class="htm-ref"> 1.&#9;</span>Desai G, Chandra PS. Ethical issues in treating pregnant women with severe mental illness. <span class="italic">Indian J</span><span class="italic"> Med Ethics</span>. 2009;6(2):75–77. <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&amp;db=PubMed&amp;list_uids=19517649&amp;dopt=Abstract"><span class="pubmed-crossref">PubMed</span></a></p>
  <p class="references-references-text-1-9"><a name="ref2"></a>2.<span class="htm-ref">&#9;</span>Coverdale JH, McCullough LB, Chervenak FA, et al. Clinical implications of respect for autonomy in the psychiatric treatment of pregnant patients with depression. <span class="italic">P</span><span class="italic">sychiatr Serv</span>. 1997;48(2):209–212. <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&amp;db=PubMed&amp;list_uids=9021852&amp;dopt=Abstract"><span class="pubmed-crossref">PubMed</span></a> <a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.1176/ps.48.2.209"><span class="pubmed-crossref">doi:10.1176/ps.48.</span><span class="pubmed-crossref">2.209</span></a></p>
  <p class="references-references-text-1-9"><a name="ref3"></a><span class="htm-ref"> 3.&#9;</span>Beck RW, Morris JB, Beck AT. Cross-validation of the Suicidal Intent Scale. <span class="italic">Psychol Rep</span>. 1974;34(2):445–446. <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&amp;db=PubMed&amp;list_uids=4820501&amp;dopt=Abstract"><span class="pubmed-crossref">PubMed</span></a> <a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.2466/pr0.1974.34.2.445"><span class="pubmed-crossref">doi:10.2466/p</span><span class="pubmed-crossref">r0.1974.34.2.445</span></a></p>
  <p class="references-references-text-1-9"><a name="ref4"></a>4.<span class="htm-ref">&#9;</span>Andrade C. The safety of duloxetine during pregnancy and lactation. <span class="italic">J&#160;Clin Psy</span><span class="italic">chiatry</span>. 2014;75(12):e1423–e1427. <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&amp;db=PubMed&amp;list_uids=25551238&amp;dopt=Abstract"><span class="pubmed-crossref">PubMed</span></a> <a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.4088/JCP.14f09631"><span class="pubmed-crossref">doi:10.4088/JCP.14f09631</span></a></p>
  <p class="references-references-text-1-9"><a name="ref5"></a>5.<span class="htm-ref">&#9;</span>Hoog SL, Cheng Y, Elpers J, et al. Duloxetine and pregnancy outcomes: safety surveillance findings. <span class="italic">Int J Med Sci</span>. 2013;10(4):413–419. <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&amp;db=PubMed&amp;list_uids=23471302&amp;dopt=Abstract"><span class="pubmed-crossref">PubMed</span></a> <a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.7150/ijms.5213"><span class="pubmed-crossref">doi:10.7150/ijms</span><span class="pubmed-crossref">.5213</span></a></p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-author"><span class="bold">Yu-Chih Shen, MD, PhD</span><span class="superscript">a,b</span></p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-author"><a href="mailto:shengmp@gmail.com">shengmp@gmail.com</a></p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="superscript">a</span>Department of Psychiatry, Tzu-Chi General Hospital, Hualien, Taiwan</p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="superscript">b</span>Department of Psychiatry, School of Medicine, Tzu-Chi University, Hualien, Taiwan</p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="bold-italic">Potential conflicts of interest: </span>None.</p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="bold-italic">Funding/support: </span>None.</p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="bold-italic">Published online:</span> October 27, 2016.</p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="italic">Prim Care Companion CNS Disord 2016;18(5):</span><span class="doi italic">doi:10.4088/PCC.16l01963</span></p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="italic">© Copyright 2016 Physicians Postgraduate Press, Inc.</span></p>
</div>
Manage Subscriptions
/_layouts/images/ReportServer/Manage_Subscription.gif
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/ManageSubscriptions.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x80
0x0
FileType
rdl
350
Manage Data Sources
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DataSourceList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x20
FileType
rdl
351
Manage Shared Datasets
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DatasetList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x20
FileType
rdl
352
Manage Parameters
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/ParameterList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rdl
353
Manage Processing Options
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/ReportExecution.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rdl
354
Manage Cache Refresh Plans
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/CacheRefreshPlanList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rdl
355
View Report History
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/ReportHistory.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x40
FileType
rdl
356
View Dependent Items
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DependentItems.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rsds
350
Edit Data Source Definition
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/SharedDataSource.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rsds
351
View Dependent Items
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DependentItems.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
smdl
350
Manage Clickthrough Reports
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/ModelClickThrough.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
smdl
352
Manage Model Item Security
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/ModelItemSecurity.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x2000000
FileType
smdl
353
Regenerate Model
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/GenerateModel.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
smdl
354
Manage Data Sources
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DataSourceList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x20
FileType
smdl
351
Load in Report Builder
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/RSAction.aspx?RSAction=ReportBuilderModelContext&list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x2
FileType
smdl
250
Edit in Report Builder
/_layouts/images/ReportServer/EditReport.gif
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/RSAction.aspx?RSAction=ReportBuilderReportContext&list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rdl
250
Edit in Report Builder
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/RSAction.aspx?RSAction=ReportBuilderDatasetContext&list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rsd
250
Manage Caching Options
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DatasetCachingOptions.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rsd
350
Manage Cache Refresh Plans
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/CacheRefreshPlanList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}&IsDataset=true
0x0
0x4
FileType
rsd
351
Manage Data Sources
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DataSourceList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x20
FileType
rsd
352
View Dependent Items
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DependentItems.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rsd
353
Compliance Details
javascript:commonShowModalDialog('{SiteUrl}/_layouts/itemexpiration.aspx?ID={ItemId}&List={ListId}', 'center:1;dialogHeight:500px;dialogWidth:500px;resizable:yes;status:no;location:no;menubar:no;help:no', function GotoPageAfterClose(pageid){if(pageid == 'hold') {STSNavigate(unescape(decodeURI('{SiteUrl}'))+'/_layouts/hold.aspx?ID={ItemId}&List={ListId}'); return false;} if(pageid == 'audit') {STSNavigate(unescape(decodeURI('{SiteUrl}'))+'/_layouts/Reporting.aspx?Category=Auditing&backtype=item&ID={ItemId}&List={ListId}'); return false;} if(pageid == 'config') {STSNavigate(unescape(decodeURI('{SiteUrl}'))+'/_layouts/expirationconfig.aspx?ID={ItemId}&List={ListId}'); return false;}}, null); return false;
0x0
0x1
ContentType
0x01
898
Document Set Version History
javascript:SP.UI.ModalDialog.ShowPopupDialog('{SiteUrl}/_layouts/DocSetVersions.aspx?List={ListId}&ID={ItemId}')
0x0
0x0
ContentType
0x0120D520
330
Send To other location
javascript:GoToPage('{SiteUrl}/_layouts/docsetsend.aspx?List={ListId}&ID={ItemId}')
0x0
0x0
ContentType
0x0120D520
350

Information Links

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Information for Authors (JCP) | Information for Authors (PCC) | Reprints and Permissions | CNS Job Market | Information for Advertisers | Media Relations | Machine-Readable JCP Archive

Help

Contact us | Unsubscribe from Elerts | Customer Service | FAQ | About JCP | About PCC | About Psychiatrist.com

Our Family of Sites

Psychiatrist.com | The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry | The Primary Care Companion | The CME Institute | Strong Veterans
Anonymous