Editor for JCP’s Early Career Psychiatrists section explains how reviewing a manuscript is akin to adopting the mindset of an emergency department physician and applying the diagnostic process to each aspect of the manuscript. Dr Goldberg provides an overview of some statistical measures and types of studies. He gives examples on how to become a critical reader, further describing what constitutes a critical review and instructing how to provide helpful criticism to the author and editor.
Insights May 24, 2021
Writing, Reviewing, and Publishing Scientific Articles, Part 3: Applying a Diagnostic Approach to Peer Review
Vol 86 • 2025 • Number 2
Read the Current Issue
Original Research
Incidence and Risk Factors for Suicide Attempt During Pregnancy and Postpartum
Original Research
Valbenazine in Elderly Adults With Tardive Dyskinesia
Academic Highlights
Optimizing Treatment With Aripiprazole Monohydrate: Pharmacokinetic Advantages of Long-Acting Injectable Formulations, A Consensus Panel Report
Original Research
Older Adults Visiting Emergency Departments for Mental Health Issues:A CHIRPP Database Study
Consensus Statement
Developing a Treatment-Resistant Depression Consultation Program, Part I: Practical and Logistical Considerations
Brief Report