The Weekly Mind Reader: The Power of Meta-Analysis

by Staff Writer
December 8, 2023 at 2:05 PM UTC

The Primary Care Companion for CNS Disorders published a paper that suggests the use of trait mindfulness-based interventions might help reduce anxiety levels in students who present with severe problematic social media use.

Meta-analysis is a crucial statistical technique for combining results from multiple studies. It’s especially valuable in fields like medicine, where research findings can vary. An ongoing series written by Chittaranjan Andrade, MD, breaks down the definitions used in meta-analysis in a way that makes them simple to understand.

A Straightforward Definition

At its core, meta-analysis averages results from different studies. The result is a comprehensive summary estimate, also known as a pooled estimate. To illustrate, consider several studies that report weight gain after 12 weeks of treatment with a drug like clozapine, each showing different average weight gains. Meta-analysis would average these numbers to arrive at an overall average weight gain, thus providing a clearer picture of the drug’s effect.

Precision plays a critical role in meta-analysis. The standard error of the mean (SEM), where a smaller SEM indicates greater precision, suggests that the study’s mean value more accurately represents the true population mean. The SEM is influenced by the standard deviation (SD) and the study’s sample size. A smaller SD and a larger sample size lead to a smaller SEM, signifying a higher precision of the mean. In the meta-analytic process, studies with more precise values are assigned greater importance. This ensures that more accurate studies have a significant impact on the final pooled estimate.

Associated Challenges

However, meta-analysis can be challenging when studies report results in different units. For example, some studies report body mass index (BMI) in pounds, while others report the stat in kilograms. To overcome this, means are converted into a common unit, typically the standard deviation (SD), allowing for a valid averaging of outcomes, even when expressed in different units. It’s an approach that ensures consistency and comparability across various studies.

Rectifying Differences

Another important aspect of meta-analysis is the comparison of mean differences between groups, commonly seen in randomized clinical trials that compare two different treatments. The mean difference indicates the extent to which one group’s results differ from another’s, which can be averaged across multiple studies for a more accurate assessment. When studies use different measurement scales, the standardized mean difference (SMD) is used. SMD standardizes the mean differences across studies, enabling meaningful comparisons, especially when outcomes are measured in different units.

Interpreting mean difference and SMD is crucial. A mean difference or SMD of zero implies no difference between groups. Positive values indicate an increase in the outcome for the experimental group compared to the control group. Negative values indicate a decrease.

Both mean difference and SMD are essential. The mean difference provides a direct, clinically understandable measure, while the SMD offers a standardized, statistical perspective. Together, they enhance the understanding of the magnitude and importance of treatment effects in clinical studies.

For more details on this topic, read Andrade’s full paper. Follow his series to help refresh your knowledge and make more informed decisions based on the study results you read.

IN OTHER PSYCHIATRY AND NEUROLOGY NEWS

  • Blockbuster weight loss drug semaglutide is proving useful in other ways, including the treatment of alcohol use disorder. 
  • Study finding’s pinpointed the factors  that are common predictors or risk factors in treatment-resistant depression.
  • As few as one hot yoga class a week can reduce depression by as much as 60 percent. Attending more classes may have an even greater benefit. 
  • A new review explores the role of monoclonal antibodies in the screening, assessment and treatment of mild cognitive impairment and early Alzheimer’s disease. 
  • Lateral eye movements appear to be a major trigger in brain zaps.
  • Follow our Youtube channel for insightful psychiatry and neurology videos. This one features Leslie Citrome, MD discussing emerging treatment approaches for schizophrenia that show promise.

NEW AT CME INSTITUTE

Click to earn free accredited CME credit.

Severity of Antipsychotic-Induced Cervical Dystonia Assessed by the Algorithm-Based Rating System

Rater consensus data were compared with deviation angle data using AI-based deviation angle measurement technology. With the range of tilt angles found in the study, the authors propose a global standard for evaluating abnormal deviation severity in cervical dystonia for future d...

Toshiya Inada and others

Unlocking Therapeutic Potential: The Role of Theta Burst Stimulation in Multiple Sclerosis Management

Theta burst stimulation interventions may hold promise in addressing specific multiple sclerosis symptoms, notably fatigue and spasticity.

David F. Lo and others