The Primary Care Companion for CNS Disorders

CME Institute

Home | About Us | Mission Statement | All CME Activities | MyCME | CME Facebook | CME Twitter

JCP

Home | About JCP | Subscribe | Archive | Information for Authors | Information for Reviewers | Information for Advertisers | CNS Job Market | Customer Service | JCP Facebook | JCP Twitter

PCC

Home | About PCC | Register | Archive | Information for Authors | Information for Reviewers | PCC Facebook | PCC Twitter

Help

FAQ | About Psychiatrist.com | Terms of use | Privacy policy

magnifying glass for search

  • magnifying glass for search
  • Advanced Search

Login

Login  
Login | Login Help | Register | Subscribe
Register | Elerts

Quick Links

Font: A | A | A

Top

Purchase PDF

Vol 19, No 4
Table of Contents

Facebook ShareShare

twitter shareTweet This

envelope iconEmail a link

Related ►

Related Articles

[X]

<p class="frontmatter-fieldnotes disclaimernew" style="margin-bottom:15px;">This work may not be copied, distributed, displayed, published, reproduced, transmitted, modified, posted, sold, licensed, or used for commercial purposes. By downloading this file, you are agreeing to the publisher’s <a href="/pages/termsofuse.aspx" target="_blank">Terms & Conditions</a>.</p> <div id="_idContainer000">
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-title"><span class="bold"><a id="_idTextAnchor000"></a>Loss of Meaning in the Era of </span><span class="bold-italic">DSM</span><span class="bold"> and Psychopharmacology</span></p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text"><span class="semibold">To the Editor: </span>When addressing changes in symptom severity in patients with psychiatric disorders, it is important to consider psychosocial stressors before jumping to pharmaceutical interventions. Here, 2 cases are presented to illustrate this point.</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text">&nbsp;</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text"><span class="semibold-ital">Case 1.</span> Ms A is a 54-year-old woman with a <span class="italic">DSM-5</span> diagnosis of recurrent major depressive disorder in remission on fluoxetine 20 mg daily. At a follow-up visit, she had symptoms of a relapse: more than 2 weeks of depressed mood, low energy, fatigue, reduced sense of joy, anxiety, poor concentration, insomnia, ruminations, and poor appetite. My initial knee-jerk response to this change was to increase the dose of her medication. However, through the interview, I learned that Ms A was off work due to a recent shoulder injury. She was very worried that she would not be able to support herself if she did not get paid during this period. This excessive worrying had led to worse mood, more anxiety, and other biological symptoms of a relapse. During the appointment, we called her company’s human resources department. She learned that she would be paid during the time off due to her medical condition. I did not increase the dose of her medication, and she left the office in a better mood. At follow-up 2 weeks later, Ms A met <span class="italic">DSM</span>-5 criteria for remission.</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text"><span class="semibold-ital">Case 2.</span> Mr B is a 24-year-old man who lost 2 of his childhood friends in a car accident while he was driving. He was devastated by the loss and met <span class="italic">DSM-5</span> criteria for severe posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) with frequent flashbacks and nightmares. He was going through a court proceeding, which could lead to years in prison if he was charged with vehicular manslaughter. Treatment with sertraline and cognitive-behavioral therapy reduced his symptoms to moderate PTSD (PTSD Checklist–Civilian version<span class="htm-cite"><a href="#ref1">1</a></span> [PCL-C] score<span class="thinspace"> </span>=<span class="thinspace"> </span>49) prior to his court session. I saw him 2 days after the court session during which he was found not guilty of manslaughter and sentenced to 18 months of call probation. At this time, Mr B did not meet criteria for PTSD, and his symptoms were subclinical (PCL-C score<span class="thinspace"> </span>=<span class="thinspace"> </span>22).</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text">&nbsp;</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text">Neither of these patients requested documents supporting illness severity for the court or work, which rules out secondary gain. With a solely psychopharmacologic mindset, both of these patients would require medication dose increases (to address major depressive disorder relapse and to further improve PTSD). Current treatment guidelines’ approach to patients is similar to the research they are based on: treat a constellation of symptoms for a designated time period regardless of psychosocial factors. However, patients similar to those presented here may have a better response to psychosocial intervention than medication dosage increase, which could explain moderate treatment response in clinical trials<span class="htm-cite"><a href="#ref2">2</a></span> based solely on symptoms and excusing etiology. The same applies to many cases of “treatment-resistant” conditions due to ongoing psychosocial stressors.</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-body-text">I believe it may be time to fine-tune our approach to mental illness in both research and clinical practice and explore nonbiological etiology more extensively. Decades ago, clinicians were inclined to find roots of all mental illness in childhood and neglected biological etiologies. I am afraid that in the current era, we may be focusing too much on medications in addressing mental illness to the point that we overlook the role of something as simple as clarifying worker compensation status for a patient with symptoms of a major depressive episode.</p>
  <p class="references_references-heading"><span class="smallcaps">Reference</span></p>
  <p class="references-references-text-1-9"><a name="ref1"></a><span class="htm-ref"> 1.&#9;</span>Blevins CA, Weathers FW, Davis MT, et al. The Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist for <span class="italic">DSM-5</span> (PCL-5): Development and initial psychometric evaluation. <span class="italic">J&#160;Trauma Stress.</span> 2015;28:489–498. <a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/jts.22059"><span class="pubmed-crossref">doi:10.1002/jts.22059</span></a></p>
  <p class="references-references-text-1-9"> 2.&#9;Arroll B, Elley CR, Fishman T, et al. Antidepressants versus placebo for depression in primary care. <span class="italic">Cochrane Database Syst Rev</span>. 2009;(3):CD007954.</p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-author"><span class="bold">Arash Javanbakht, MD</span><span class="superscript">a,b</span></p>
  <p class="ltrs-br-ltr-br-author"><a href="mailto:ajavanba@med.wayne.edu">ajavanba@med.wayne.edu</a></p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="superscript">a</span>Director, Stress, Trauma, and Anxiety Research Clinic, Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Neurosciences, Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan</p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="superscript">b</span>Department of Psychiatry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor</p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="bold-italic">Potential conflicts of interest:</span> None.</p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="bold-italic">Funding/support:</span> None.</p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="bold-italic">Patient consent:</span> The patients provided permission to publish these cases.</p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="bold-italic">Published online:</span> July 20, 2017.</p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="italic">Prim Care Companion CNS Disord 2017;19(4):17l02092</span></p>
  <p class="doi-line"><span class="italic">https://doi.org/</span><span class="doi">10.4088/PCC.17l02092</span></p>
  <p class="end-matter"><span class="italic">© Copyright 2017 Physicians Postgraduate Press, Inc.</span></p>
</div>
Manage Subscriptions
/_layouts/images/ReportServer/Manage_Subscription.gif
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/ManageSubscriptions.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x80
0x0
FileType
rdl
350
Manage Data Sources
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DataSourceList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x20
FileType
rdl
351
Manage Shared Datasets
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DatasetList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x20
FileType
rdl
352
Manage Parameters
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/ParameterList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rdl
353
Manage Processing Options
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/ReportExecution.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rdl
354
Manage Cache Refresh Plans
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/CacheRefreshPlanList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rdl
355
View Report History
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/ReportHistory.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x40
FileType
rdl
356
View Dependent Items
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DependentItems.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rsds
350
Edit Data Source Definition
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/SharedDataSource.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rsds
351
View Dependent Items
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DependentItems.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
smdl
350
Manage Clickthrough Reports
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/ModelClickThrough.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
smdl
352
Manage Model Item Security
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/ModelItemSecurity.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x2000000
FileType
smdl
353
Regenerate Model
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/GenerateModel.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
smdl
354
Manage Data Sources
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DataSourceList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x20
FileType
smdl
351
Load in Report Builder
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/RSAction.aspx?RSAction=ReportBuilderModelContext&list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x2
FileType
smdl
250
Edit in Report Builder
/_layouts/images/ReportServer/EditReport.gif
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/RSAction.aspx?RSAction=ReportBuilderReportContext&list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rdl
250
Edit in Report Builder
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/RSAction.aspx?RSAction=ReportBuilderDatasetContext&list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rsd
250
Manage Caching Options
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DatasetCachingOptions.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rsd
350
Manage Cache Refresh Plans
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/CacheRefreshPlanList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}&IsDataset=true
0x0
0x4
FileType
rsd
351
Manage Data Sources
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DataSourceList.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x20
FileType
rsd
352
View Dependent Items
/PCC/article/_layouts/ReportServer/DependentItems.aspx?list={ListId}&ID={ItemId}
0x0
0x4
FileType
rsd
353
Compliance Details
javascript:commonShowModalDialog('{SiteUrl}/_layouts/itemexpiration.aspx?ID={ItemId}&List={ListId}', 'center:1;dialogHeight:500px;dialogWidth:500px;resizable:yes;status:no;location:no;menubar:no;help:no', function GotoPageAfterClose(pageid){if(pageid == 'hold') {STSNavigate(unescape(decodeURI('{SiteUrl}'))+'/_layouts/hold.aspx?ID={ItemId}&List={ListId}'); return false;} if(pageid == 'audit') {STSNavigate(unescape(decodeURI('{SiteUrl}'))+'/_layouts/Reporting.aspx?Category=Auditing&backtype=item&ID={ItemId}&List={ListId}'); return false;} if(pageid == 'config') {STSNavigate(unescape(decodeURI('{SiteUrl}'))+'/_layouts/expirationconfig.aspx?ID={ItemId}&List={ListId}'); return false;}}, null); return false;
0x0
0x1
ContentType
0x01
898
Document Set Version History
javascript:SP.UI.ModalDialog.ShowPopupDialog('{SiteUrl}/_layouts/DocSetVersions.aspx?List={ListId}&ID={ItemId}')
0x0
0x0
ContentType
0x0120D520
330
Send To other location
javascript:GoToPage('{SiteUrl}/_layouts/docsetsend.aspx?List={ListId}&ID={ItemId}')
0x0
0x0
ContentType
0x0120D520
350

Information Links

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Information for Authors (JCP) | Information for Authors (PCC) | Reprints and Permissions | CNS Job Market | Information for Advertisers | Media Relations | PPP COVID-19 Statement

Help

Contact us | Unsubscribe from Elerts | Customer Service | FAQ | About JCP | About PCC | About Psychiatrist.com

Our Family of Sites

Psychiatrist.com | The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry | The Primary Care Companion | The CME Institute | Strong Veterans
Anonymous